Mo-Cap: It Gives Chimps Souls! By Vince Mancini
Rise of the Planet of the Apes opened to $54 million domestically and rave reviews over the weekend, with critics describing the motion-capture effects as “astonishingly effective,” among other things, and many calling for the guy in the digital chimp suit, Andy Serkis, to be considered a legitimate contender for supporting actor honors. In many cases, they seemed even more impressed by the film than the studio’s own marketing, which is no small feat. Assorted quotes from the making-of featurette:
“This is the first live-action film that has its main character as a thoughtful, feeling, self-aware animal.” -Rupert Wyatt, Director
“WETA brought their technology to another level for this movie to make our apes look real.” -Dylan Clark, Producer
“Andy Serkis is unlike any other actor. He can inhabit characters that don’t speak and emote in ways that you don’t often see in movies.” -Dylan Clark, Producer
“The basic usage of performance capture is that on screen you will see apes, but they’re apes which are infused with the heart and soul of an actor’s performance.” -Andy Serkis
“This film is not possible without the work of Andy Serkis.” -Producer
“Everybody’s seen chimpanzees, they’ve seen orangutans, we know how they’re supposed to look. So I think the bar in terms of needing to make photorealistic characters is really high.” -Erik Winquist, WETA VFX Supervisor
“One of the improvements in motion-capture since Avatar really have to do with detail. And the type of imagery that they’re getting out of the cameras gives us more facial information. And that subtlety is what’s going to make the apes work.” WETA Animator
“My first reaction to seeing it was, that’s Andy Serkis looking like a chimp! And that was what was so amazing, that you get to see his performance.” -Rupert Wyatt
“We’ve managed to put the soul within this character. And that comes through the actor’s performance.” -Rupert Wyatt
Wyatt isn’t the only filmmaker in town with a big boner for motion-capture right now, and rightly so (see also: Tintin). It’s the new toy. As with any new toy, you have to play around with it for a while to figure out what its strengths and limitations are. I actually liked ROTPOTA, so (for me) it certainly passed the most important test there. But the hype is starting to get nauseating, and hailing motion-capture as this revolutionary technology is a bit premature. We seem to be in the same stage of development with performance capture that we were with microwave ovens in the 60s, when people were still expecting them to bake entire, golden-brown chickens. Mo-cap certainly has its place, I just don’t think we’ve quite perfected what that is yet. And it shouldn’t become such a go-to that people forget that there are other types of effects that are pretty damned good too, types of effects that still (and may always) accomplish certain things better.
Read the rest of this entry »