
Melissa with something that she’d like Rex Reed to sit on.
Rex Reed is a 74-year old film critic who once famously wrote the following sentence about South Korean people in his review for the film Old Boy:
“What else can you expect from a nation weaned on kimchi, a mixture of raw garlic and cabbage buried underground until it rots, dug up from the grave and then served in earthenware pots sold at the Seoul airport as souvenirs?”
He also started the rumor that Marisa Tomei only won the Best Supporting Actress Oscar in 1992 because Jack Palance was wasted when he presented the award. So basically, Reed is a cranky, cantankerous assh*le, and he wants to remind us of that with his new review of Identity Thief in the New York Observer.
In the trashy, stupefying screenplay by Craig Mazin, Jason Bateman is a Denver accountant named Sandy Patterson—another in a long line of victims of the increasingly dangerous world of cyber-crime—whose credit card has been hacked and copied by a felonious thief in Miami (cacophonous, tractor-sized Melissa McCarthy).
Hold on, folks. Rex ain’t done.
The snafus in the worst road movie since The Guilt Trip plunge Mr. Bateman and his female hippo into a motel with only a double bed, a grotesque sex scene with a pickled reprobate she picks up in a bar who demands a threesome, a violent bar fight that bloodies his nose, a kidnapping, a multi-car collision going the wrong way on the freeway … but why go on?
No, please do go on, you incredibly out-of-touch, misogynistic shitbag fossil.
Melissa McCarthy (Bridesmaids) is a gimmick comedian who has devoted her short career to being obese and obnoxious with equal success.
That’s rich. The cranky, old film critic is calling the overweight actress a gimmick. Well played, irony. Well played.
(Banner via Helga Esteb / Shutterstock.com)



She’s way too short to be a tractor…
That was my first thought.
Isn’t saying Identity Thief is “the worst road movie since The Guilt Trip” In February 2013 like saying Friday is the worst day of this week since Thursday?
Exactly what I was going to comment about…. what an idiot
She’s Larry the cable guy with slightly bigger boobs and sleeves.
People who are fat but not funny are not actually people. They’re like gingers.
Please take this time to kiss my fat, funny, red haired ass.
Well, OK, if you say so, but that seems weird. Ewwww, man, that tastes like soulless arse…wait a minute.
And suck my dick while your at it, might taste better
Your not funny. I also sincerely doubt your the only one on the internet with a beard.
Sounds like someone *cough, AMB, cough* has a crush on Melissa “Hungry Hungry” McCarthy.
I’m not defending Rex Reed though, he’s a scabby old git.
While some of the initials are the same (and our last names have the same letters), Burnsy and I are not the same person.
I never knew that! I always thought the bylines just alternated to confuse us.
So you’re saying you don’t have a crush on Melissa McCarthy, but that Burnsy does?
*raises hand* Me! I would like to crush our mutually obese frames together in a naked-type situation.
Yes, Rex, fatty on fatty action! How you like them tractor-sized apples?
Rawhead, I would never speak for Burnsy, but I’d go with your gut on this one.
But if Armond White called her a rotund pachyderm everyone would be gobbling his balls?
If Armond White had called her a rotund pachyderm we would have just ignored it, because that is how we respond to Armond White.
I mean really, what kind of fantasy world do you live in where people gobble Armond White’s balls?
Armond White would never have gone for the easy “she’s fat” take. No, he would have gone on at length about the movie is a fascinating explication of the Jewish/Irish socioecopoliticalized relationship, but that Spike Lee could have done it better.
If Melissa McCarthy is tractor-sized then I’m pretty sure I know why American agribusiness is losing so much money. She’s barely smart-car-sized.
As Arnold Schwarzenegger would say, “My shoo eez biggah dan Melissa McCarthy!”
Can all future posts about rex reed be accompanied by this photo of him? [www.newyorksocialdiary.com]
Pretty sure this is much more accurate, though.
I can’t see the image. what was it of?
I love that asshole will get you blocked by the censors but shitbag gets a pass. You just have to stay on the bleeding edge of insults and you can say anything you want Vince!
Burnsy.
sure, rex reed is a shrivelled up old dick, but geez this movie looks fucking awful. I’ve no doubt mccarthy has comedic talent, but in today’s hollywood, the ONLY roles available for her are “hey, look at that CARAAAAAAAAZY FAT CHICK!!!!!!!”
Yes, she and Tina Fey or Anna Faris aren’t exactly competing for the same parts. It must suck to be a woman in Hollywood, once you deviate from the prescribed boundaries (age, weight, etc.) you’re screwed. Whereas Sylvester Stallone (just one example) gets to keep up his he-man persona indefinitely.
Yeah, “non-standard” performers can be successful, but they’re the lucky ones who found a niche or who had SO much talent that the Man couldn’t Keep Them Down.
Yeah, Hollywood acts like fat girls are the Highlander: there can be only one (and we must remind her of how fatty fat she is at every point).
Misogynistic? Really? Out-of-touch shitbag fossil, I’ll give you. But I’d say he’s more sizist in general than misogynistic. Either that or he *really* fucking hates threesomes…
Well.. is he wrong?
yeah, she can be funny. He didn’t mention that.
All he’s doing is making the implicit subtext of the comedy in the film explicit. Alot of the film’s unspoken humor is “ha ha, this chicks fat….even if it doesn’t come right out and say it. You should be just as pissed at the filmmakers as Rex Reed as the film is every bit as cruel. The only difference is Reed has the balls to say it outright.
Perfect! She can play Tractor-Hippo, the fourth villain in the Spiderman sequal.
I was thinking she could be Mrs. Rhino so she could blow shit at Rhino about him never spending time with the kids.
Rosencrantz & Guildenhippo are Dead?
So we are shitting on Rex for being honest? I think the whole, hey look I’m fat and that’s hiiiilarious died with the Chris Farley/Patrick Swayze Chippendale’s skit on SNL.
No, we’re shitting on Reed for being a fucking asshole. He was tasked with reviewing a movie and managed to work in uncalled-for cheap shots at a cast member. Calling Melissa McCarthy “fat” or “overweight” is honest. Calling her “tractor-sized” or a “female hippo” is something that useless pieces of shit like Rex Reed do. And yes, I realize the irony of my calling Reed a piece of shit for insulting others, but his attacks on McCarthy were unwarranted. I’m calling him out for what he did, not what he looks like.
*initiates slow clap*
Her looks are a product of her own life choices. She’s not fat because it’s her race or nationality. She’s fat because 100% guilty if eating like a tractor sized hippo.
She is a fat tub of shit. He was being nice.
NO that is when it LIVED
I got 20 bucks that says Rondogg isn’t a pound under 250.
“Felonious Thief” sounds redundant, but he is a jazz legend.
A+
Is it just me or is she just doing the typical “IM FAT FARRRRTTTTT” routine but changing it up to “IM FAT QUEEEEFFFFFFF”
She’s an unfunny slob. Reed might be completely politically incorrect, but he’s not factually incorrect. She’s not a few lbs overweight like when everyone started cracking on Jessica Simpson. McCarthy is morbidly obese. It’s not entertaining of funny. It’s disgusting and sad.
How is he factually correct? She’s neither a farming vehicle nor a non-human animal.
Jessica is that you?
baiting up your troll pole? Nice one dick face.
@King Dann, I genuinely laughed out loud. Thank you for that.
@Irishame – Yar welcomes! ^_^
Fat isn’t a slur, it’s just something you are.
That’s how Quentin T justified the N-word.
Fair play, so by that logic Rex Reed is a washed-up f@g film critic?
But if one points out that an aged queen made fun of a large woman, I’d be the bad guy.
Why is it okay to say to a tall person “hey you’re really tall, do you play basketball or something?” but it’s not okay to say to a fat person “hey you’re really fat, do you sumo wrestle or something?”
COZ SUMO BOYS WORK HARD FOR THEYS PRIVILEGES. Foo.
Yep. These are identical questions to have. The same way dem Orientals love it when people say “Hey, you’re really Celestial, do you make karate or something?” Also, if you ever see someone with a weird face, make sure you approach them with, “Hey, you you’re really retarded looking, did your mom drink basically every night of her pregnancy or something?” Just an innocent Joe, asking innocent questions.
; )
Tractor?! Don’t hardly know h… *a shy exibitionist banging a Melissa McCarthy real doll on the ledge of a ten story building nut shoves it over the edge which plummets to the street below crushing Crappy to the deathness*
Damn Crappy, your slashfic is giving me a tractor beam, if’n you know what I’m saying.
I love when fat actors die of obesity-related health issues. That shit kills me every time.
Be careful you don’t cut yourself with that edge.
I think Rex is secretly sad he is not Melissa McCarthy.
Hmmm, nice try Rex, but it’s not quite up there with falling asleep at the screening and giving the dream you had a negative review, that’s easily still your best work.
The scene in the trailer where she’s stuffing her face and says “do they like ribs?” is puke city.
Sorry if I’m going to sound like a troll, but, isn’t being a tractor-sized hippo for LULZ is what Melissa McCarthy is going for? Practically everything she has done is based on physical comedy because obese chick.
Or maybe Rex is just sick and tired of all the fucking trailers with “Lap Dance” playing in the background and he just snapped when he got essentially a Happy Gilmore productions movie?
Well, to be perfectly fair, she has talked about wishing she was magically smaller and wishing she could get cast in other roles, but she doesn’t want to hate on herself and give a bad message to daughters—so I think at that point, you take what you can get? It’s rough being a woman in Hollywood, man. You aren’t thin/white/pretty and you can’t get 90% of the stuff out there, so if you’re heavy, that’s your main asset.
And like, it’s not easy to lose weight if your body wants to be that way, so it’s not just as easy as being rich and getting some fancy surgery. So yeah, she does do that comedy, but what other roles is can she really get? How many roles do fat girls get that don’t revolve around the HEY I’M A GIRL WHO’S FAT? shtick?
“Practically everything she has done is based on physical comedy because obese chick.”? Really? I think the majority of her comedy is based on allowing her to improve and be funny. Her humor is no more based in physicality than any of her female contemporaries. In fact, I would argue a hack like Cameron Diaz or Sandra Bullock is far more rooted in physical comedy than she is. And they’re not even good at it!
I don’t know why Rex Reed has to being appearance into it, but I have to admit I don’t find Melissa McCarthy very funny, including In Bridesmaids.
Wholly terrible autocorrect, Batman. Being=bring.
Saw a preview for the movie, it looks the stoopid. But some people will watch anything.
Imagine a world where you are blind and have never seen MM.
Then you meet her. You hear that sickly wheeze that is her voice. You run your fingers over her puffy face to form an image of her in your mind. She chokes out an offer to have sex with you.
You reply “Pass” and begin vomiting uncontrollably.
Sorry, but I don’t think this is the right forum for your erotic fanfic :/