
The Just for Laughs Festival has been going on in Montreal, and over the weekend, the full text of the keynote address delivered by my favorite comedian, Patton Oswalt, hit the web. Oswalt’s keynote was a two-part open letter, one to fellow comedians, and another to “gatekeepers in broadcast and cable executive offices, focus groups, record labels, development departments, agencies and management companies.”
Here’s that one:
Dear gatekeepers in broadcast and cable executive offices, focus groups, record labels, development departments, agencies and management companies:
Shalom.
Last month I turned in a script for a pilot I co-wrote with Phil Rosenthal who has had a share of luck and success I can only dream of. Thanks for the notes you gave me on the pilot script. I’m not going to be implementing any of them.
And no, I’m not going to call you “the enemy” or “the man.” I have zero right to say that based on the breaks I’ve gotten from you over the years. If I tried to strike a Che Guevara pose, you would be correct in pointing out that the dramatic underlighting on my face was being reflected up from my swimming pool.
I am as much to blame for my uneasiness and realization of late that I’m part of the problem, that I’m half asleep and more than half complacent.
And I’m still not going to implement your notes. And I’m quoting Phil Rosenthal on this, but he said after we read your notes – and I’m quoting him verbatim – “We’re living in a post-Louie world, and these notes are from a pre-According to Jim world.”
I just read a letter to my fellow comedians telling them what I’m about to tell you, but in a different way. Here it is.
You guys need to stop thinking like gatekeepers. You need to do it for the sake of your own survival.
Because all of us comedians after watching Louis CK revolutionize sitcoms and comedy recordings and live tours. And listening to “WTF With Marc Maron” and “Comedy Bang! Bang!” and watching the growth of the UCB Theatre on two coasts and seeing careers being made on Twitter and Youtube.
Our careers don’t hinge on somebody in a plush office deciding to aim a little luck in our direction. There are no gates. They’re gone. The model for success as a comedian in the ’70s and ’80s? That was middle school. Remember, they’d hand you a worksheet, fill in the blanks on the worksheet, hand it in, you’ll get your little points.
And that doesn’t prepare you for college. College is the 21st century. Show up if you want to, there’s an essay, there’s a paper, and there’s a final. And you decide how well you do on them, and that’s it. And then after you’re done with that, you get even more autonomy whether you want it or not because you’re an adult now.
Comedians are getting more and more comfortable with the idea that if we’re not successful, it’s not because we haven’t gotten our foot in the door, or nobody’s given us a hand up. We can do that ourselves now. Every single day we can do more and more without you and depend on you less and less.
If we work with you in the future, it’s going to be because we like your product and your choices and your commitment to pushing boundaries and ability to protect the new and difficult.
Here’s the deal, and I think it’s a really good one.
I want you, all of the gatekeepers, to become fans. I want you to become true enthusiasts like me. I want you to become thrill-seekers. I want you to be as excited as I was when I first saw Maria Bamford’s stand-up, or attended The Paul F. Tompkins show, or listened to Sklarbro Country….
I want you to be as charged with hope as I am that we’re looking at the most top-heavy with talent young wave of comedians that this industry have ever had at any time in its history.
And since this new generation was born into post-modern anything, they are wilder and more fearless than anything you’ve ever dealt with. But remind yourselves: Youth isn’t king. Content is king. Lena Dunham’s 26-year-old voice is just as vital as Louis CK’s 42-year-old voice which is just as vital as Eddie Pepitone’s 50-something voice.
Age doesn’t matter anymore. It’s all about what you have to say and what you’re going to say. Please throw the old f*cking model away.
Just the tiny sampling at this amazing festival…. I’m excited to not be the funniest person in the room. It makes me work harder and try to be better at what I do. So be as excited and grateful as I am.
And if in the opportunities you give me, you try to cram all this wildness and risk-taking back in to the crappy mimeographic worksheet form of middle school, we’re just going to walk away. We’re not going to work together. No harm no foul. We can just walk away.
You know why we can do that now? Because of these. (Oswalt holds up an iPhone)
In my hand right now I’m holding more filmmaking technology than Orsen Welles had when he filmed Citizen Kane.
I’m holding almost the same amount of cinematography, post-editing, sound editing, and broadcast capabilities as you have at your tv network.
In a couple of years it’s going to be f*cking equal. I see what’s f*cking coming. This isn’t a threat, this is an offer. We like to create. We’re the ones who love to make sh*t all the time. You’re the ones who like to discover it and patronize it support it and nurture it and broadcast it. Just get out of our way when we do it.
If you get out of our way and we f*ckin’ get out and fall on our face, we won’t blame you like we did in the past. Because we won’t have taken any of your notes, so it’ll truly be on us.
I don’t know if you’ve seen the stuff uploaded to Youtube. There are sitcoms now on the internet, some of them are brilliant, some of them are “meh,” some of them f*ckin suck. At about the same ratio that things are brilliant and “meh” and suck on your network.
If you think that we’re somehow going to turn on you later if what we do falls on its face, and blame you because we can’t take criticism? Let me tell you one thing: We have gone through years of open mics to get where we need to get. Criticism is nothing to us, and comment threads are f*cking electrons.
Signed,
Patton Oswalt [via TheComic'sComic]
It’s all smart and well said, and the people he intends it for would do well to heed the advice, though I don’t expect them to. We may be living in a post-Louie world, but networks are still trying to create the next Two and a Half-Men for the enormous, underground cave full of mouth-breathers I assume exists somewhere near Idaho that actually watched that show. (C’mon, advertisers! Cave dwellers don’t even buy sunscreen!). I predict a good 10 years of us all knowing that a change is coming and being bored as sh*t while we wait for it to actually come. Kind of like Game of Thrones. You know how they said “Winter is coming?” Then a whole goddamn season goes by, still no winter. (Though in Game of Thrones’ case, I forgive the lack of winter on account of all the horseback fingerbanging).
Also, I think he totally meant to mention the Frotcast along with those other podcasts. Probably just an oversight. Oh, and commenters, you’ll be happy to know that even after years of open mics, comment threads do occasionally hurt my feelings. Usually because of the poor spelling, but every once in a while genuine sadness that someone hates me. But that’s what keeps me grounded, you know? That and this prosthetic leg.



I suspect the Idaho-based Two and a Half-Men viewers are more tolerable than the California-based Entourage viewers.
In the same way that McDonalds french fries are more tolerable than TGIF sweet potato fries.
Those network executives didn’t get their leather-encrusted BMWs listening to advice from comedians. The saddest thought of the day will be one of said executives passing Patton’s speech along to a focus group to see how it tests and how they can best respond to it.
The profits associated with a show like 2.5 Men are roughly equivalent to three billion seasons of Louie. Very few executives would think that the notes they provide to Patton Oswalt will make his show “funnier,” they think the notes will make it “more popular,” which is an entirely different thing.
Harumph.
Sadly, Jonson has a point. Networks don’t care about funny any more than they care about quality or originality (that’s why they make the same thing over and over). They only care about profits – the end. Show them decreasing profits from the old model, and greater profits from a new model and you can get them on board. Problem is, the Youtube stuff Patton is talking about makes shit money, and reruns of according to Jim make more than all the independent stuff combined.
Now, I’m gonna go have a nice little cry at my desk.
You stole someone’s prosthetic leg? Asshole.
Flannery O’Connor’s dead nipples just got hard.
Spoiler alert: winter does come.
It does? That stupid white raven doesn’t count.
Also, I sincerely hope that he dropped the mic at the end of that speech.
SHOW ME THE
MONEYMONE– MONE– TIZATION, PATTON! SHOW ME THE MONETIZATION!These come to Jesus moments work best in Tom Cruise movies. Television was invented 25 years before anyone figured out how to use it and it remains f*cked to this day. New technologies expect to fare any better?
LOVE the tone, wit and execution of this speech but I think you nailed it sir: “…networks are still trying to create the next Two and a Half-Men….” The difference between the internet and the real world is enormous and it’s way to easy to get myopic about life on the internet and conflate the two as equals. Everything Patton mentions, WTF, Paul F. Tompkins Show, Sklarbro Country, etc. are geared for and patronized by fans of, for lack of a better phrase, the comedy elite. Those fans are a very small percentage of the entertainment consuming public. Louie is my favorite show on television but his numbers are paltry compared to The Big Bang Theory. For every Paul F. Tompkins there are two or three Jon Cryers ready and willing to eat creative shit and regurgitate it back into the mouths of a mildly interested populace for a dump truck full of cash (to borrow Krusty the Klown’s weakness). The people this address is intended for are more likely to back that dump truck into to Cryer’s drive way than take a career shot with an alternative comedian’s esoteric vision. Also, Louis CK happens to be a genius, most people can’t do what he does.
That’s the irony. We have the example of how Television went wrong from which to work, however because it made bazillions for folks in the past, everyone is going to use the parts that went wrong in hopes of striking gold.
It took a while to get there, but I think I understand your point with this post, Vince.
I’m sorry I made fun of your clown hair. Jokes between dudes on the internet have their limits, and I think I found them. Still pals?
Manny Delgado: The College Years
We all know this is coming.
This is an incredible letter but I’d take issue with the point that CK “revolutionized” live tours considering the fact that he’s playing nothing but small venues on his self-sold tour and there isn’t a single show in the entire Philadelphia to Atlantic City area. Once someone breaks Ticketmaster’s exclusive hold on venues then we can say they revolutionized the industry, playing small independent venues in Wisconsin and places like that has always been possible.
Signed, a disgruntled CK fan who lives somewhere between Philadelphia and Atlantic City.
I think Patton was referring to the point that you don’t have to have Louis CK come to Philadelphia or Atlantic City to see his standup because he posts in on the internet for $5.
@Alcoholics Gratuitous Except for the fact that he clearly said “comedy recordings” and “live tours” separately.
How bout making a 2-hour drive down to Baltimore on New Years Eve to see him at “small independent venue” the Meyerhoff Symphony Hall. Sure, you have to spend several hours in Bmore, but it’s New Years Eve! Just get shit-faced enough to forget where ya are (after the Louie show, of course).
Does this mean that I’ll finally find a network buyer for my script “The Theory of How I Banged Your Big Mother”?
…2 1/2 Times: NCIS.”
If I learnt one thing from that letter it’s that I need to upgrade my phone.
YEAH NETWORKS, MOAR COMEDY THAT A SMALL AMOUNT OF PEOPLE THINK IS FUNNY. FORGET THE MOUTH BREATHER DOUCHEBAGS WHO AREN’T AS SMART AS US BECAUSE IF YOU DONT LIKE OUR BRAND OF COMEDY YOU’RE PROLLY RETARDED BECAUSE WE’RE SUPER SMART. JUST ASK US WE’LL TELL YA. GET OUT OF OUR WAY AS YOU PAY US LARGE SUMS OF YOUR MONEY THAT WAY IF WE SCREW UP WE HAVE NO ONE TO BLAME BUT OURSELVES. BY THE WAY, THIS LETTER ISN’T ANTI-SEMITIC AT ALL JUST KINDA SEEMS THAT WAY. BASICALLY WE WANT TO BE TRUST FUND BABIES WITHOUT ANY OF THE RULES.
That’s some good trollin’. The anti-semitism jab is the icing.
Truth.
Oswald is correct insofar as the execs aren’t needed to do the things he does.
…
and most of the country has never seen what he does. And only a small percentage of those who haven’t would like it if they did. He’s smart and funny and elitist and insulting to a great number of people. The same people who buy pickup trucks and McDonald’s and Wal-Mart and all the other shit he hates and which pays the bills with commercials.
This is nothing more than a very cleverly written pandering for financial backing with no thought for the consequences of failure. “Oh, Patton, YOU won’t blame the exec if YOU fall on your face? How generous of you. Think maybe the guy in the bigger office down the hall from said exec might feel otherwise? Yeah, maybe. And it’s not their job to answer to you. It’s their job to make themselves and other people money. So sit down, shut up and be glad you were allowed to speak to the same said execs who may someday be willing to make you or one of your super talented friends obscenely wealthy.”
He’s making a plea for people to be fans of the shit they try to sell to other people. Is that really such an impossibly idealistic notion, to attempt to sell things you’re proud of and not just shit that will make you money? It seems like it’s either “integrity” or “faggotry,” depending on how much of an asshole you are.
Haha, that’s a pretty good burn. I agree with everything Patton said and there’s no bigger fan of him than me, but he has to realize by now that his comedy has a smaller audience than what a network is going for. Louie works because FX’s business model is really smart. Find a few talented people, give them a budget and hand over the reins. Eventually you land a cult hit.
But all this talk about a revolution coming… Sorry to break it to you Patton but the world will always be mostly filled with people who would rather laugh at mother-in-law jokes.
Don’t worry Vince, when I achieve my inevitable destiny by becoming an asshat entertainment executive, I will never give you any notes about Fecal Transplant Hospital. Except to a) make it more like House and b) it must include Breckin Meyer. But after that, no notes. Pinky swear and everything.
We’ll call it “Arse.”
Patton makes an excellent point, and I think this would make a brilliant 5 second film.
PATTON gets a delivery from a SEXY FEDEX LADY.
He immediately rips open the packaging to find his prize, the spec script he submitted to “Big Hollywood Studio.” Patton flips through the pages to reveal a ton of red ink and post-it notes full of suggestions.
“FUCK YOU!” he screams at the top of his lungs.
Sexy Fedex Lady is startled by the scream, as she jumps back in surprise, her boobs jiggle.
Fin.
Isn’t that letter kind of a longer, more-articulate/less-jokey way of saying “give us somma that internet munnnnayyy”?
It is a strong argument that accurately conveys a growing trend of artists finding their own market. Many in the music industry are ahead regarding this. Does this mean Patton thinks Justin Bieber is a genius?
“In my hand right now I’m holding more filmmaking technology than Orsen Welles had when he filmed Citizen Kane.”
Great, Patton. Too bad there’s no app to make a hack into Welles.
I love Patton Oswalt the comedian. Patton Oswalt the wanna-be intellectual (which you get plenty of if you follow him on twitter) gets old fast.
I agree. I love his stand-up, but his social commentary offstage is grating, elitist, hipster bullshit, best exemplified by his borderline unreadable, masturbatory essays in Zombie Spaceship Wasteland. I went into that book a hardcore Oswalt fan, and came out of it wanting to dangle him over a precipice by the waistband of his tighty whities.
See, I love Louis C.K. And I think his show is hilarious in that it’s trying and talking about things other shows won’t. But the show is really kind of an absurdist version of Seinfeld in that nothing really happens. So episodes are hit and miss based on if you find the entire joke he’s going for in the episode funny. If you don’t appreciate “is she giving birth? nope just farting” jokes, you’re not really gonna like that one episode. And the same goes for a lot of them. The show’s really at its best when its just him and his friends riffing off each other in my opinion.
Anyone else find the “According to Jim” and “Two and a Half Men” bashing ironic considering Phil Rosenthal created “Everybody Loves Raymond”?
The guy is one of the unfunniest hacks around and Patton is delusional if he thinks he can break new comedy ground working with Phil.
That was my first thought. Rosenthal made nine figures off of that show. Also, Louie is a niche show on a niche network that draws a niche audience on a niche budget. It’s not like it’d pull in 10mm a night if only it were on NBC in primetime.
I really don’t get why Rosenthal / Everyone Loves Raymond are given so much credit. I never thought the show was funny. But I’ve met a number of people with good taste who feel otherwise.
Patton Oswalt is saying this for so many of us in so many of the fields of art. Eat shit, gatekeepers. The one thing, though, for those in the performing world…advertisers. Them gatekeeper dudes gots the advertisers on the their speed dials. That’s the crux still. It’s changing, and if the advertisers had any sense they’d see Indies don’t have the overhead. We’re not after hundreds of thousands per 30 second. Not even tens of thousands. Think about that. The free market rules, and artists are now free…thanks to technology.
All a good reason for those of us starving and considering an extraordinary suicide (or just giving up) to hang on.